Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
Friday 20 December 2024, 02:15:44 am

Login with username, password and session length

Visit the Official Endian Bug tracker  HERE
14262 Posts in 4377 Topics by 6517 Members
Latest Member: Sandro
Search:     Advanced search
+  EFW Support
|-+  Announcements
| |-+  Project News
| | |-+  Endian Fork - Looking for members !
0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic. « previous next »
Pages: [1] 2 3 Go Down Print
Author Topic: Endian Fork - Looking for members !  (Read 343790 times)
aender
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


WWW
« on: Wednesday 07 July 2010, 06:57:52 pm »

Endian - Security WITHOUT Passion !?

Hello.

Look at this:
w w w .efw-forum.de/www/forum/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=713

Anyone who can translate this to english?
Logged

Help us to create a real endian community at http://endian.secureit.at
tvriasi
Jr. Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 6


« Reply #1 on: Wednesday 07 July 2010, 11:06:30 pm »

(Google Translate Wink )

Hello people.

I am Endian reseller and currently has more than dissatisfied with the conduct of the company Endian to resellers or customers. Not to mention the quality of the current 2.3 Enterprise or 2.4 community. At mails from customers and resellers, if any, responded only very weak and cryptic. Support Cases will be deported. Even with known bugs that have long been hushed up and be easy. The best example is released 8 months since the 3.2-existing QoS that works to this day is useful or not. There is no clear commitment for or against the community. Even repeatedly offered assistance in testing, development, troubleshooting, be more or less ignored. All together here in the forum to explain exactly would get out of hand and for no purpose.

In short: the current status for me is no longer tenable.

All this has brought me to the decision to found a new fork of the EFW!

Unfortunately, this is not quite so simple and needs the support of a good, functioning community. Therefore my appeal to everyone: MAKE WITH!

The aim should be:

- Highest priority should be a functioning, stable 2.4.
- Currently known bugs need to be addressed shortly.
- All modules mounted on a date (ClamAV, SpamAssassin, Squid, ....)
- SVN repository, documentation of sources
- Wiki, FAQ, bug tracker - with faster response times and properly described bugfixes
- Forum for developers and the community
- Later, an add-on system and new features

Sure some things are missing here. Anyone who has suggestions or wants to participate should contact us by personal message to me.

My humble self is currently in development (programming) might help "nor" not much, since I'm not a programmer. But that can change quickly. I am willing to learn.
However, I can offer a server of the entire project can host. Trouble Shooting and search for bugs, I assume even you. Translation I do already.

So you are all welcome.
Send me your ideas, wishes, suggestions may appear as a Platform / Fork / should.

What tools should be used?
Who can contribute what?
etc.

Would appreciate a successful fork.

P.S. - I'm also very dissapointed about v2.4...
 Sad
Logged
wavrunrx2
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 12


« Reply #2 on: Thursday 08 July 2010, 03:35:46 am »

My appeal to everyone: MAKE WITH!

 Tongue

i support an endian fork 100%
Logged
den64
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 28


« Reply #3 on: Friday 09 July 2010, 04:05:33 am »

Hi,

I offer my help as tester.

Thankz
Logged
burja2
Jr. Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 8


« Reply #4 on: Friday 09 July 2010, 10:23:57 pm »

Dear community members,

Endian.com is what it is: a company. Let's face it, they're leveraging on many open source softwares without giving proper means for the community to contribute in an effective manner.

Endian Corp doesn't have an open svn/git repository where developer can peruse and share code or having coding standards and documentation to circumvent the current "obscurity shroud" put in place over the source code, which is taking form of things such as: awkward kernel versions that aren't able (or locked?) to not recognise basic hardware such as embedded usb wireless cards, etc.  Hey Endian Corp... your hotspot functionality doesn't worth all the pain you're impose to everyone in deploying cutted down linux kernel functionalities or weird customized things in such a way that hardware isn't properly detected or running properly (apart of heavily bugged functionalities that still plague 2.4 version...)

Respect toward the community, previous developers & teams (smoothwall coders, etc.) and the open source spirit is beginning with such basic things.  Without respect, how Endian could expect something from community?

IMHO, this is pretty much a closed product now, Exploiting open sources by walking inside a "gray area" dangerously close to goes against GPL licencing's principles/philosophy if it's not against their rules (a potential litigation case for FSF? :-) ) 

So, to all community members being frustrated trying to make something happen with endian, instead of forking, maybe you can check for alternatives such as Untangle, NetCop (they have an hotspot too), pfsense even astaro.

Cheers,
Logged
wavrunrx2
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 12


« Reply #5 on: Saturday 10 July 2010, 03:47:43 am »

i may be moving to pfsense or astero soon.
Logged
mrkroket
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Posts: 495


« Reply #6 on: Saturday 10 July 2010, 03:59:31 am »

And again, we start what is somewhat killing the adoption of Linux, forking.
You linux ppl love to fork, Endian forked from IPCop, PfSense from smoothwall, zillions of forks around ubuntu, even Google!
I think that 10 people working together must produce a better product than 5 groups of 2 people working in parallel about the same issues.
We'll probably repeating the same work!

I completely agree about all the big problems around Endian 2.3. I didn't fully tested 2.4, so I can't say anything.
Lack of support, critical bugs that are not fixed on community, etc. etc..
I needed to invest tons of hours to get my 2.3 ironed. Happily, now it's rock stable for me, and simply works => Boss happy  Cheesy => Big Boss happy  Cheesy => me happy  Grin

Maybe we dont need a fork, just a working group that creates an unofficial 2.4.1 release, with all bugs fixed.
And an open SVN to synchronize with.
Once you clear up some problems, the system is very powerful, more than many commercial ones ($$$$$$$$$)
Quote
The aim should be:

- Highest priority should be a functioning, stable 2.4.
- Currently known bugs need to be addressed shortly.
- All modules mounted on a date (ClamAV, SpamAssassin, Squid, ....)
- SVN repository, documentation of sources
- Wiki, FAQ, bug tracker - with faster response times and properly described bugfixes
- Forum for developers and the community
- Later, an add-on system and new features
Agree on all, except on the add-on system. This is the thing I most hate on IPCop.
Everything should be on the main package. If you need it, power on the service. If you don't, leave it off, just like now.
Otherwise there won't be any control, and any new version release could be a hell (it happens to me on IPCop).

Logged
DFen
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 46


« Reply #7 on: Saturday 10 July 2010, 04:40:40 pm »


Maybe we dont need a fork, just a working group that creates an unofficial 2.4.1 release, with all bugs fixed.
And an open SVN to synchronize with.


I agree with mrkroket

I believe the main problem at the moment is the conspicuous absence of developers who are able or willing to assist with the issues - possibly this is simply a lack of feedback from them.

I would be happy to help out with specific problems - my main issue is lack of assistance with kernel/install issues.
Logged
aender
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


WWW
« Reply #8 on: Sunday 11 July 2010, 02:52:59 am »

OK.

Letīs do it.

I will setup a server with Redmine h t t p :// w w w .redmine.org/
In my opinion this would be a good platform for developers with all that we need. Also i create a SVN with the available sources from endian.

Think this should be up and running at 13. July 2010.

Then we can discuss at the forum there for all that we need.
Logged

Help us to create a real endian community at http://endian.secureit.at
den64
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 28


« Reply #9 on: Sunday 11 July 2010, 06:09:24 pm »

Hi guys,

I suggest you try Ipfire, iv'e been testing it and so far its not too bad. But  I still like Endian though, but feature wise its better than endian in some area's.

Still waiting for that fork,  :  )


Logged
aender
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


WWW
« Reply #10 on: Monday 12 July 2010, 11:14:12 pm »

OK.

Itīs up and running....

h t t p : / / e n d i a n.secureit.at
Logged

Help us to create a real endian community at http://endian.secureit.at
DFen
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 46


« Reply #11 on: Monday 12 July 2010, 11:25:26 pm »

aender

I thinl your will need a register/login page (I cannot see one)
Logged
aender
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 10


WWW
« Reply #12 on: Monday 12 July 2010, 11:27:35 pm »

in the right upper corner you find register ..../account/register
Logged

Help us to create a real endian community at http://endian.secureit.at
raccoonia
Jr. Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 1


« Reply #13 on: Sunday 08 August 2010, 04:10:50 am »

Hello all,

I have to completely disagree with mrkroket and the way this "fork" is going..
Please dont compare apples with oranges here. One should look on the reasons people are concidering a fork.
So before we start discussing about IPCop forking to Endian and some Ubuntu forks, lets take a look at the situation here and now with Endian:

- The most important part of an Open Source Project is its community. Where do you see Endian S.r.l. having a community? Where is the communication?

- You very correctly say:
Quote
10 people working together must produce a better product than 5 groups of 2 people working in parallel about the same issues.
How many people of the COMMUNITY do you see working on the project? Let me take a wild guess. 0?

-
Quote
We'll probably repeating the same work!
Do you even know what work Endian S.r.l. is doing behind closed doors? Were were all desperately waiting for a fix to 2.3 when all of a sudden we got a new major release with the same bugs and as a cherry on top, a few more.

- Speaking of Open Source, please read again burja2's post above. Apparently Endian S.r.l. hasnt posted any full source code for two versions now.

-
Quote
I completely agree about all the big problems around Endian 2.3. I didn't fully tested 2.4, so I can't say anything. Lack of support, critical bugs that are not fixed on community, etc. etc.. I needed to invest tons of hours to get my 2.3 ironed. Happily, now it's rock stable for me, and simply works => Boss happy  Cheesy => Big Boss happy  Cheesy => me happy  Grin
Is there a better example on why a fork is needed? If critical bugs are fixed but Endian S.r.l. does NOT publish them for the community edition, what kind of signal does that give?
You say you spend tons of hours getting 2.3 ironed out. Now imagine you posted all those bugs on Endian's tracked and also provided for the fixes. Do you think they would all end up in the community edition, even if you managed to get hold of someone at Endian S.r.l. to inform them?

-
Quote
Maybe we dont need a fork, just a working group that creates an unofficial 2.4.1 release, with all bugs fixed. And an open SVN to synchronize with. Once you clear up some problems, the system is very powerful, more than many commercial ones ($$$$$$$$$)
Would it be a REAL Open Source project, with a REAL supported community behind it, I would support that fully. But there is no community, there is no communication between Endian S.r.l. and the people using the community edition. Having a  of unofficial forums here and there, where people using the software try to help each other, does not qualify as an open source community. In an open source community there is a healthy communication between all members working with the same goal, make the software better.

I would fully support a project that helps the PEOPLE. I will not help create a "better" Endian Firewall when the company behind it treats its community like that.

Logged
tomakos
Jr. Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 9


« Reply #14 on: Sunday 08 August 2010, 10:29:49 pm »

I am happy to see, that more and more Endian users feel exactly the same, as I do.

Yes, Endian is no community project, no matter if Endian names their free version "Community version" or not.
There is no community.

It is just a company named "Endian" who forked IPCop with the goal to steal open source software, close it up and then sell it with a profit. Endian is not open source. There are no open sources, at least not in a way, as the GPL licences say that they have to exist.
What Endian does is illegal. They violate the GPL licences of the software packages that they use for their product.

And there are some people like us, who use the free version and communicate via multiple unofficial forums that we have done in order to help us each other with this software. That is no community, either.

It is time to fork and build a true community project. But is it possible without the sources of 2.4 / only fragments of sources of older versions?

If it is possible, we should organize ourselves and fork, indeed.

But as happy as I am about the action of aender, I do not think that it was a good start.
We should organize ourselves first, find a mission and goals that we all agree to fight for. THEN we should find technical means how to achieve this goals (website, forum, version control, etc.).
It is about humans first, not about technical instruments.
It is about a community. Not about software. That's the point.

So I think that in first place we should make a list of people who are interested in participating, including their skills and how they think that they could help the project.
I can take over this part of organization.

So please:

If you are interested in helping forking Endian, please send an email to:
t-o-m@gmx.net
and give the following information:

1. Your name or nickname
2. An email that we can communicate with you
3. An Skype username, if existing, so that we can chat or make realtime group discussions, if necessary
4. Your relevant skills with level of expertise (1 beginner, 2 intermediate, 3 good, 4 expert, 5 guru)
5. Your amount of time that you will be willing to involve yourself in hours (1 a few hours per month when there is something that I can help, 2 2-3 hours per week, 3 5-8 hours per week, 4 even more)
6. Your idea(s) (if you have) about a nice name for our fork

Examples for relevant skills are:

1. Linux tools & services (e.g. knowledge in one or more of the following programs/technologies: DHCP, DNS, QoS, Proxy, Antivirus, IDS, Software RAID, Hardware RAID, UPS, HTTPD, Networking such as bonding, multi-WAN, hardware monitoring, smartd, VPN, etc., etc., etc... Just look at all the components of Endian and see if you can help in any of them. Or look if there is something that you know and you think it would be great to integrate into the fork!)

2. Web-Development for the GUI

3. Software-Development for Tools such as efw-monitor, or any other software that could enpower our fork, e.g. iPhone apps for monitoring your Endian-forks, etc., etc., etc.

4. Kernel & compiling sources & under the hood: Do you know how to build a kernel in a way that we need it? Do you know under-the-hood things about Linux that you can contribute? Do you know how to compile sources? Have you experiences in forking a project?

5. Security: Are you a network security specialist? Can you advise us about how you think that Endian-fork should be made so that we achieve the highest possible security strenghs?

6. Tester: Do you like to help by installing betas and try them out and analyze them and feedback to the developers?

7. Distribution building: Do you know how to assemble all those parts to become a turnkey-distribution in form of a bootable ISO?

8. Administrator: Do you know how to assemble computers and or to administer them so that we have a testing server?

9. Graphics: Do you know how to make nice graphics and artwork so that our endian-fork gets a nice logo, design, etc in the webinterface, on our webpage, on our CD-labels, etc.?

10. Webmaster: Do you know how to fix us a decent project website?

11. Technical tools: Do you know how to set up e.g. a webforum, a wiki, a version control, a project management software, a communication platform, a torrent for downloading our ISOs, etc. etc. etc.?

12. Software development management: Do you know how to efficiently lead a group of people to develop software in a decent, efficient, painless and nice way?

13. Project lead: Do you have project management skills so that you can lead all those people and groups of people in a way that we truly achieve the goals and the overall mission?

14. Community management & Communications: Do you know how to write nice press release texts, talk to the media, talk to our community and keep them motivated and in love with our project? Do you know how to manage conflicts in a community?

15. Do you like to document features and write a good manual/ wiki?

16. Do you speak some language other then English and like to translate things, such as the GUI, the website, press releases, etc?

17. Do you have money and/or hardware or other resources, that you want to donate? E.g Hardware for a test & development server, special add on cards e.g. RAID controllers (so that we can make the fork support them!), webspace, bandwith, cash, etc.?

18. Do you have other skills that we could need at some point? E.g. legal advisory (especially about GPL, product names, etc., the legal organization form of endian-fork).

This list is just a brainstorm that I did right now. There are surely many other way in which someone could participate. So if you think you could be useful in some way please just send this email!!
After some time when we collected some names, I will contact you via the email to discuss the next steps that we think that we should undertake to get things started.

Let's see what the result will be!

All the best
Tom
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3 Go Up Print 
« previous next »
Jump to:  

Page created in 0.188 seconds with 19 queries.
Powered by SMF 1.1 RC2 | SMF © 2001-2005, Lewis Media Design by 7dana.com